Iran promotes an arbitration center for the BRICS: a new legal order for global trade?

Royalty-free stock photograph created by Navy Medicine and Unsplash.

Governance and Dispute Resolution

Iran has formally proposed the creation of an arbitration center exclusively for the BRICS countries. This initiative seeks to establish an alternative legal framework to the Western one for resolving trade and investment disputes, generating new uncertainties for Spanish companies operating in these markets.

---

The Islamic Republic of Irán has submitted a formal proposal to establish an arbitration center dedicated exclusively to resolving trade and investment disputes between the bloc's member countries BRICSThe initiative, announced since TeheránThis represents a significant step in consolidating the group's own institutional architecture, with the aim of reducing dependence on arbitration forums traditionally located in Europa y Norteamérica.

This move is part of a broader geopolitical strategy by the bloc —comprised of Brasil, Rusia, India, China, Sudáfrica and its recent additions—to create an economic and financial ecosystem parallel to the Western one. For Spanish companies with commercial interests or investments in these markets, the proposal introduces a new factor of risk and legal complexity that will need to be managed with caution.

The rise of a parallel legal system and its impact on trade

To date, international trade disputes have been mostly settled in prestigious and recognized neutrality arbitration courts, such as the Corte Internacional de Arbitraje de la Cámara de Comercio Internacional (CCI) en París or Centro Internacional de Arreglo de Diferencias relativas a Inversiones (CIADI), attached to Banco MundialThe creation of a center BRICS It seeks to offer an alternative that, according to its promoters, would be more aligned with the interests and economic realities of emerging markets.

However, for international operators, especially European ones, this raises questions about the impartiality, transparency and enforceability of awards that are issued in this new forum. A proprietary arbitration system could benefit local companies in the countries. BRICS to the detriment of their foreign counterparts, altering the balance of power in contractual negotiations.

Analysis of the BRICS Arbitration Proposal

Concept	Description
Initiative	Creation of an exclusive arbitration center for the bloc BRICS.
bidder	Irán, as a new member of the group.
Main goal	Resolving trade and investment disputes without resorting to Western institutions.
Potential Impact for Spain	Greater legal uncertainty and the need to review dispute resolution clauses in contracts with companies from other countries BRICS.

Implications for Spanish exporting companies

Experts in international commercial law consulted by Foreign Company They warn that this initiative obliges Spanish companies to exercise greater diligence in their operations with the countries BRICSThe key points to consider are:

• Review of contractual clauses: It will be essential to negotiate and clearly specify the chosen arbitration forum in international contracts, trying to maintain venues of recognized neutrality.
• Legal risk analysis: Companies will need to assess the risk that, despite what has been agreed, a dispute may be forced to be resolved in the new center. BRICSespecially in transactions with state entities in those countries.
• Enforcement of awards: Homologation and implementation in España or Unión Europea A ruling issued by this new body could face legal and bureaucratic obstacles.
• Regulatory fragmentation: This is yet another symptom of the fragmentation of the global trade order, which requires companies to be more adaptable to divergent and, at times, conflicting regulatory frameworks.

Key points and frequently asked questions about the BRICS arbitration center

How does this proposal affect a Spanish export contract?

Directly. The dispute resolution clause is one of the most critical in any international contract. If a trading partner from one country BRICS If the company is required to resolve any disputes in this new center, it will face an unfamiliar and potentially less neutral legal framework. It is vital to ensure that an internationally recognized arbitration forum is designated during the negotiations.

Would this new arbitration center be less reliable than the current ones?

Technical reliability will depend on its regulations and the quality of its referees. However, the main concern for a Spanish company is not so much technical competence as... perceived lack of neutralityBeing an organization created by and for the bloc BRICSThere is a risk that their decisions may be influenced by the geopolitical and economic interests of the group.

What preventative measures should Spanish companies take?

The main measure is contractual prevention. Companies should seek specialized legal advice to draft "watertight" arbitration clauses that specify neutral forums and applicable law. Furthermore, it is advisable to strengthen the arbitration phase. due diligence from the business partner and consider taking out political risk insurance to cover such eventualities.